The Twisted Verdict manifests as a gavel carved from bone-black crystal, its handle wrapped in knotted cord that seems to move when unwatched. The head of the gavel is cracked, and from within the fracture pulses a dim amber light that intensifies whenever nearby delvers scheme or plot. When struck against any surface, it produces no sound but instead imprints a symbol on the nearest stone that predicts the next tag exchange. The artifact weighs exactly as much as the bearer's current number of tags, and it vibrates when a false oath is spoken nearby.

The Twisted Verdict serves as the ultimate equalizer—it exists to prevent any single mercenary from dominating through pure aggression, ensuring that those who hunt tags become vulnerable to being hunted. It chooses its own holder rather than being stolen, passing only to those delvers worthy of wielding its power.